
The Failure to Prevent Genocide in Rwanda : The Role of Bystanders.
Title:
The Failure to Prevent Genocide in Rwanda : The Role of Bystanders.
Author:
Grünfeld, Fred.
ISBN:
9789047431312
Personal Author:
Edition:
1st ed.
Physical Description:
1 online resource (329 pages)
Series:
International and Comparative Criminal Law Series ; v.23
International and Comparative Criminal Law Series
Contents:
CONTENTS -- Foreword -- Preface -- Acknowledgments -- List of Abbreviations -- List of Actors -- Glossary -- Chapter 1: Early Warnings and Early Action by Bystanders -- 1.1 Introduction -- 1.1.1 Human Rights Standards -- 1.1.2 After the Cold War -- 1.1.3 Perpetrator-Victim-Bystander Approach -- 1.1.4 Third-Party Intervention -- 1.2 The Role of the Bystander -- 1.3 Early Warning -- 1.3.1 Categorizing Early Warnings on Human Rights Violations -- 1.3.2 Linking Gross Human Rights Violations to Violent Conflicts -- 1.4 Early Action -- Chapter 2: The Tribunal's Interpretation and Implementation of the Genocide Convention -- 2.1 The 1948 Convention Definition of Genocide -- 2.2 The Rwanda Tribunal's Definition of Genocide -- 2.2.1 Akayesu's Hate Speech: Direct and Public Incitement to Genocide -- 2.2.2 Hate Propaganda by Radio RTLMC and the Newspaper, Kangura: Genocide -- Chapter 3: Rwandan History -- 3.1 German Colonial Rule -- 3.2 Belgian Colonial Rule -- 3.2.1 Belgian Introduction of Identity Cards -- 3.3 Hutu Dominance After Independence -- 3.4 Tutsi-RPF Invasion in 1990 -- 3.5 Concluding Observations -- Chapter 4: Undermining UNAMIR -- 4.1 The Arusha Peace Accords -- 4.2 The Mission of the Neutral International Force in the Arusha Peace Agreement -- 4.3 The UNAMIR Mandate -- 4.4 Differences Between the Arusha Accords and the UNAMIR Mandate -- 4.5 The Rules of Engagement and the Operational Procedure -- 4.5.1 The Rules of Engagement -- 4.5.2 The Operational Procedure for the Establishment of the Weapon-Free Zone in Kigali -- Chapter 5: The Installment of UNAMIR with Belgian Participation -- 5.1 The Preparation by the Reconnaissance Mission -- 5.2 Belgian Participation -- 5.2.1 The Only Western Country Willing to Participate -- 5.2.2 Belgium Explicitly Requested by the United Nations to Participate.
5.2.3 Belgian Awareness of the Danger of Participating in UNAMIR -- 5.3 Composition of the Peace-Keeping Force and Its Resources -- 5.3.1 No U.N. Intelligence Unit -- 5.4 Concluding Observations -- Chapter 6: Early Warning of Atrocities in 1991-1994 -- 6.1 Hutu Extremism Emerges -- 6.1.1 Military Attacks in 1991-1993 -- 6.1.2 Reaction by Bystander States in Spring 1992 -- 6.1.3 Violence Continues During Arusha Peace Negotiations 1992-1993 -- 6.2 Reports from Diplomats to the Outside World -- 6.3 Reports from Human Rights Organizations -- 6.4 Report from the U.N. Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial Executions -- 6.5 Human Rights Watch Warnings in 1993 and 1994 -- 6.6 American Warnings-CIA-in 1993 and 1994 -- 6.7 Hate Propaganda Is Reported as Early Warning -- 6.7.1 Hate Newspaper Kangura -- 6.7.2 Hate Radio Mille Collines -- Chapter 7: Early Warnings from November to January -- 7.1 A Violent Start for UNAMIR -- 7.2 The Machiavelli Plan -- 7.3 Announcements on the Distribution ofArms -- 7.4 Knowledge of the Distribution ofArms -- 7.5 Inability to Install the Broad Based Transitional Government (BBTG) -- 7.6 The First Violent Demonstration -- Chapter 8: The Genocide Fax and the Prohibition from U.N. Headquarters to Act -- 8.1 Marchal Meets Informant Jean Pierre -- 8.2 The Genocide Fax -- 8.3 The Recipients of the Fax -- 8.4 The Instructions Following the Genocide Fax -- 8.4.1 The First Response from Annan and Riza to Booh Booh -- 8.4.2 The Direct Reaction from Booh Booh to New York -- 8.4.3 New York's Reaction to Booh Booh and Dallaire -- 8.4.4 Communications Between Dallaire and New York -- 8.4.5 Dallaire's Vain Attempts to Influence Booh Booh -- 8.5 Arms Raids and the Scope of Resolution 872's Mandate -- 8.6 Conclusions on the U.N. Political Leadership of Annan, Riza and Annabi.
Chapter 9: The Negative Response of New York and Capitals in the West to the Deteriorating Situation -- 9.1 Following the Instructions After the Genocide Fax -- 9.2 The Response of the Heads of Missions of France, Belgium and the United States to the Fax of Dallaire -- 9.3 Jean Pierre Proves His Story but Is Denied Asylum -- Chapter 10: Deteriorating Security in Rwanda and the Negative Response from New York from January Up Until March -- 10.1 Political Deadlock in the Arusha Peace Agreements -- 10.2 January 1994 -- 10.3 February 1994 -- 10.4 March 1994 -- 10.5 April 1994 -- 10.6 Concluding Observations -- Chapter 11: Requests from Dallaire and from Belgium to New York for a Stronger and Firmer Broadened Mandate for UNAMIR -- 11.1 Dallaire's Requests to Seize Arms -- 11.1.1 Failure of U.N. Top Officials -- 11.2 Belgium Asks for a More Robust Role for UNAMIR -- 11.3 Conclusion -- Chapter 12: UNAMIR: Its Mandate and the Offending Belgian Role -- 12.1 SC Resolution 909, April 5, 1994: A Possibility to Broaden the UNAMIR Mandate -- 12.2 The American Attitude Toward Peace-Keeping in 1994 -- 12.3 Continuing Anti-Belgian Feeling -- 12.4 Radio Broadcasts Reinforce the Anti-Belgian Climate -- 12.5 Anti-Belgian Incidents -- 12.6 Belgian Peace-Keepers: An Easy Target -- Chapter 13: The Start of the Genocide -- 13.1 Indifference as to Who Shot the Plane Down -- 13.2 The First 12 Hours Following the Plane Crash -- 13.2.1 A Denial of Prime Minister Agathe Uwilingiyamana's Authority -- 13.2.2 UNAMIR Fails to Protect Madame Agathe -- 13.2.3 The Killings Start with a Politicide -- 13.2.4 Contact Between Riza and Dallaire in the First Hours After the Crash -- 13.3 Death ofTen Belgian Peace-Keepers -- 13.3.1 Jean Pierre's Prediction Becomes Reality -- 13.3.2 New York's First Response upon the Death of the Ten Belgian Paramilitary Commandos.
13.3.3 Marchal and Dewez Heavily Criticized in Belgium -- 13.4 Conclusion -- Chapter 14: Evacuation -- 14.1 U.S. Reaction to the Crash -- 14.2 Evacuation by the American Military -- 14.3 Evacuation by the French Military -- 14.4 Evacuation by the Belgian Military -- 14.5 U.N. Role in the Evacuation -- 14.6 Conclusion on the Possible Preventative Role of the EvacuationForces -- Chapter 15: Belgian Decision to Withdraw Its Troops -- 15.1 Introduction -- 15.2 Belgian Efforts to Change the Mandate -- 15.2.1 Belgium Asks for an Explanation of the Mandate Immediately After the Plane Crash -- 15.2.2 Belgium Requests a Change of the Mandate After the Death of the Ten Paramilitary Commandos -- 15.2.3 Sincerity of the Belgian Requests for a Broader Mandate -- 15.3 Belgian Participation at Stake After the Killings of the Belgian Paramilitary Commandos -- 15.4 Belgium Decides to Withdraw -- 15.4.1 The Belgian Cabinet Prepares for the Meeting of Minister Claes with the U.N. Secretary-General -- 15.4.2 Minister Claes Meets the U.N. Secretary-General on April 12 in Bonn -- 15.5 Belgium Starts Campaigning for a Total Withdrawal ofUNAMIR -- 15.5.1 Telling the World that UNAMIR Has Become Pointless -- 15.5.2 The Belgian Explanation for Its Efforts to Get a Total Withdrawal -- 15.6 Conclusion -- Chapter 16: The Response of the Security Council -- 16.1 Introduction -- 16.2 The Secretary-General's Response on the Death of the Peace-Keepers and the Belgian Withdrawal -- 16.2.1 The Secretary-General's April 8 Letter to the Security Council -- 16.2.2 Boutros-Ghali's Response to the Security Council After His Meeting with Minister Claes -- 16.3 The Security Council: What to Do After the Belgian Withdrawal -- 16.3.1 April 13: A Meeting of Troop-Contributing States and an Informal Security Council Meeting.
16.3.2 April 14: An Informal Security Council Meeting-Three Options Are Presented to the Council -- 16.3.3 April 15: Another Informal Security Council Meeting-A Decision Without Saying "No" -- 16.4 DPKO Suddenly Wants a Total Withdrawal -- 16.4.1 Information from Dallaire to New York -- 16.4.2 Reverse Reaction from New York by Riza on Input from Dallaire -- 16.4.3 Annan Favors Withdrawal -- 16.5 Boutros-Ghali Suddenly Comes Up with an Option to Reinforce the Mission -- 16.6 Unanimous Adoption of Resolution 912: Leaving a Symbolic Number of Peace-Keepers Behind -- 16.7 Resolution 918: UNAMIR II, Enforcement Up to 5,500 Troops -- Chapter 17: The Role of the Netherlands Throughout the Genocide -- 17.1 The Dutch Role in UNOMUR and UNAMIR -- 17.2 Meetings During the Genocide Within International Organizations and the EU -- 17.3 Rwanda in the Dutch Parliament -- 17.4 Dutch Non-Role in Peace-Keeping -- 17.5 Pronk's Visits to Rwanda -- 17.6 Efforts to Alleviate the Refugee Problems in Goma -- Chapter 18: Apologies from Bystanders Ten Years Later -- 18.1 Apologies from Belgium -- 18.2 Apologies from the United States -- 18.3 Apologies from France -- 18.4 Apologies from the European Union -- 18.5 Apologies from the African Union -- 18.6 Apologies from the United Nations -- 18.6.1 Early and Clear Warning -- 18.7 Lessons Learned at U.N. Summit 2005 -- Chapter 19: Conclusions -- Annexes -- 1 Scheme "Hurivic," Human Rights Violations and Conflict -- 2 Organization and Composition of UNAMIR -- 3 Fax Dallaire -- 4 List of Early Warnings -- Bibliography -- Index.
Abstract:
This volume is about the failure to prevent genocide in Rwanda in 1994. In particular, the research focuses on why the early warnings of an emerging genocide were not translated into early preventative action. The warnings were well documented by the most authoritative source, the Canadian U.N. peace-keeping commander General Romeo Dallaire and sent to the leading political civil servants in New York. The communications and the decisionmaking are scrutinized, i.e., who received what messages at what time, to whom the messages were forwarded and which (non-) decisions were taken in response to the alarming reports of weapon deliveries and atrocities. This book makes clear that this genocide could have been prevented.
Local Note:
Electronic reproduction. Ann Arbor, Michigan : ProQuest Ebook Central, 2017. Available via World Wide Web. Access may be limited to ProQuest Ebook Central affiliated libraries.
Genre:
Added Author:
Electronic Access:
Click to View