Cover image for Point Counterpoint : Universal Grammar in the second language.
Point Counterpoint : Universal Grammar in the second language.
Title:
Point Counterpoint : Universal Grammar in the second language.
Author:
Eubank, Lynn.
ISBN:
9789027281791
Personal Author:
Physical Description:
1 online resource (449 pages)
Series:
Language Acquisition and Language Disorders ; v.3

Language Acquisition and Language Disorders
Contents:
POINT COUNTERPOINT UNIVERSAL GRAMMAR IN THE SECOND LANGUAGE -- Editorial page -- Title page -- Copyright page -- Dedication -- Table of Contents -- Introduction: Universal Grammar in the Second Language -- " Plato's Problem" -- Theory of Learning -- The Epistemology of Language-Particular Grammar -- The Ontology of Grammar -- Set Theory and Partimeters -- Neurobiology and Maturation -- Second Language Research -- Early L2 Research -- Universal Grammar and 12 Acquisition: the 1980's -- The Logical Problem of Foreign Language Learning -- Point Counterpoint -- Conclusion -- References -- Seven Trivia of Language Acquisition -- "Language acquisition is a difficult and cumbersome process which extends over many years until fullmastery is achieved." -- "Language acquisition is essentially accumulative." -- "The process of language acquisition presupposes avast amount of input as well as species-specificlearning capacities." -- "The input consists of sound waves and of parallel situational information." -- "The target of the acquisition process is to interrelate expressions and meanings." -- "Language acquisition is the result of many essentially interacting processes." -- "Principianonsunt multiplicandapraeter necessitatem." -- Conclusion -- References -- Seven Not-So-Trivial Triviaof Language Acquisition: Comments on Wolfgang Klein -- The Logical and Developmental Problems of Acquisition -- Input -- Situational Information -- Acquisition as a Result of Interacting Processes -- The Target of Acquisition -- Modularity -- Conclusion -- References -- The Accessibility of Universal Grammar in Second Language Acquisition -- References -- Issuesin the Accessibility Debate: A Reply to Felix -- Accessibility -- Clarifications -- Reanalysis -- References -- Age-Dependent Effects in Language Acquisition: An Evaluation of "Critical Period" Hypotheses.

Speech/Accent -- Argument 1: Fixed Period for Acquisition -- Argument 2: Biological Basis for a Critical Period -- Argument 3: Modularity and Categorical Perception -- Other Possible Contributions to Age Effects on L2 Accent -- Syntax -- Ostensible Arguments in Favor of a Critical Period for UG -- General Arguments Against the "Anti- UG" Position -- Counterarguments: Part 1 -- Counterarguments: Part 2 -- Summary of Arguments -- An L2 Acquisition Example -- Conclusion -- References -- On the Notion of "Critical Period"in UG/L2 Theory: A Response to Flynn and Manuel -- Prefatory Remarks -- The Notions of "Critical Period" and "Age-Dependent Effects" -- The Relevance of Evidence from Speech and Speech Perception -- Evidence from Grammaticality Judgments -- Conclusions -- References -- Second Language Competence versus Second Language Performance: UG or Pro cessing Strategies -- Competence and Performance -- Reception versus Production -- Acquisition and Operating Principles -- L1 Acquisition of German Word Order -- Processing Strategies and the L2 Acquisition of German Word Order -- UG Revisited -- Conclusion -- References -- Processing, Constraints on Acquisition, and the Parsing of Ungrammatical Sentences -- References -- Linguistic Knowledge in Second Language Acquisition -- White -- Felix -- References -- Appendix Grammaticality Judgment Test Sentences -- Transfer or Universal Grammar: Reply to Jordens -- White -- Felix -- References -- Principles of Universal Grammar and Strategies of Language Use:On some Similarities and Differences between First and Second Language Acquisition -- UG in First and Second Language Acquisition -- The UG/L2 Approach -- Problems with the UG/L2 Approach -- Summary and Research Goals -- Principles of UG versus Strategies of Language Processing -- Maturational Constraints on Language Acquisition.

Triggering and/or Learning: The Kind of Evidence Needed -- Surface Word Order: A Case of Non-Parametric Learning -- Agreement Phenomena: Triggering of Knowledge in L1 - Learning in L2 -- The Role of Verb Inflection in Grammar -- Verb Inflection in Adult and Child L2 Acquisition -- Conclusions -- References -- Conceptual and Empirical Evidence: A Response to Meisel -- Validity of Argumentation -- Verb-Placement Developmental Sequence -- Empirical Adequacy (Or What Counts as Evidence?) -- Motivation for OVand V°-to-I° Movement -- MeiseVs Counter-Evidence to the Change to OV -- Native-speaker German is SOVI -- Triggers for the Changes in Headedness -- Conclusion -- References -- Accessto Universal Grammar in Second Language Acquisition -- UG and the LAD -- Null Subjects and the MUP -- L1Acquisition -- L2 Acquisition -- Method -- Subjects, Results, and Discussion: Child L2 Acquisition -- Subjects, Results, and Discussion: Adolescent L2 Acquisition -- Subjects, Results, and Discussion: Adult L2 Acquisition -- Default or L1 Values -- Conclusion -- References -- Language Acquisition and the "Pro-Drop" Phenomenon: A Response to Hilles -- First Language Acquisition and "Pro Drop" -- Second Language Acquisition and "Pro Drop" -- Conclusion -- References -- Binding Parameters in Second Language Acquisition -- Governing Categories -- L2 Acquisition and Binding Theory -- Proper Antecedents -- GCP and PAP -- Conclusions -- References -- Appendix -- Do Second Language Learners Have "Rogue" Grammars of Anaphora? -- References -- Morphological Uniformity and Null Subjects in Child Second Language Acquisition -- Morphological Uniformity, Null Subjects, and L1 Acquisition -- Child L2 Acquisition of "Mixed" Languages -- Method -- Subjects -- Procedures -- Results and Discussion -- Marta -- Muriel -- Uguisu -- Constraints on the Transfer of L1 Settings -- Conclusion.

References -- Evidence,Analogy and Passive Knowledge: Comments on Lakshmanan -- Passive Knowledge -- A Methodological Point -- Morphological Analysis and Expletive Subjects -- Conclusion -- References -- Abbreviations -- Index.
Abstract:
Point Counterpoint offers a series of papers and replies originally presented at a special session of the Second Language Research Forum, UCLA, March 1989. The focus of the papers is primarily the role of Universal Grammar in second language acquisition, though the agenda also includes discussion of other fundamental questions, viz., the explanatory potential of linguistic theory in native-language development. It may come as no surprise that the contributors and their respondents often present very different perspectives on the issues, for most of the authors were known in advance to hold contrasting points of view. Contributors (c) and Respondents (r) are: Wolfgang Klein (c)/Nina Hyams (r); Sascha Felix (c)/Jacquelyn Schachter (r); Suzanne Flynn & Sharon Manuel (c)/David Birdsong (r); Lydia White (c)/Robert Bley-Vroman (r); Peter Jordens (c)/Lynn Eubank (r); Jurgen Meisel (c)/Bonnie Schwartz (r); Sharon Hilles (c)/William O'Grady (r); Daniel Finer (c)/Margaret Thomas (r); Usha Lakshmanan (c)/Nina Hymans & Ken Safir (r).
Local Note:
Electronic reproduction. Ann Arbor, Michigan : ProQuest Ebook Central, 2017. Available via World Wide Web. Access may be limited to ProQuest Ebook Central affiliated libraries.
Electronic Access:
Click to View
Holds: Copies: